Parental Rights in Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania Parental Rights News
We have been busy in Pennsylvania this year. With a lot of momentum behind us and a lot of opportunities ahead of us, we need your support to continue our vital efforts in your Commonwealth. First, we worked with allies from across the political spectrum to oppose House Bill 1737, which would have allowed Child…
Pennsylvania State Law and Parental Rights
Pennsylvania does not have a state statute that explicitly defines and protects parental rights as fundamental rights.
2019-2020: Rep. James Cox, with 16 cosponsors, introduced HB 508, a bill to protect parental rights, on April 9, 2019. It was referred to the Committee on Children and Youth, and hasn’t moved out for a House vote.
If you're a PA resident, please call members of committee, especially the chair, Rep. Boback, to vote it out. We also encourage you to call your State Reps. to co-sponser the bill.
2015-16: Rep. Tallman, with 12 cosponsors, introduced HB1512, a bill to protect parental rights, on Aug. 26, 2015. It was referred to the Committee on Children and Youth, but it did not receive a hearing.
Don't Miss a Critical Issue!
Pennsylvania Courts and Parental Rights
"Strict Scrutiny" Applied to Parental Rights
Pennsylvania courts have repeatedly recognized the rights of parents to oversee the care of their children as a fundamental right deserving of the strict scrutiny standard. However, this precedent is subject to change.
- In Schmehl v. Wegelin, 927 A.2d 183, 188 (Pa. 2007), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled that "any infringement of such right [parental rights] requires strict scrutiny review to determine whether the infringement is supported by a compelling state interest and if the infringement is narrowly tailored to effectuate that interest," citing Troxel v. Granville, 530 U.S. 57, at 65.
- D.P. v. G.J.P., 2016 Pa. LEXIS 2003 (Pa. Sept. 9, 2016):
"There is no dispute that Section 5325 burdens the right of parents to make decisions concerning the care, custody, and control of their children; that such right is a fundamental one; and that, as such, it is protected by the Fourteenth Amendment's due-process and equal-protection guarantees. In light of these factors there is also no disagreement that, to survive a due process or equal protection challenge, Section 5325 must satisfy the constitutional standard known as strict scrutiny.
"The basic features of strict scrutiny, relating to whether the governmental action is narrowly tailored to a compelling state interest, are well established." (Internal citations omitted.)